What is a good deductible for home insurance?

Learn How to Choose the Best Deductible for Your Homeowners Insurance Policy


Many factors go into choosing the “best” deductible for your homeowner’s policy. First, let’s talk about the different types of deductibles. Typical homeowners insurance policies have 2 deductibles. The first deductible is known as the policy deductible and the second is commonly referred to as the hurricane deductible, or as known in the industry as the catastrophic windstorm deductible.

Let’s discuss the standard policy deductible. Normal options for policy deductibles are $500, $1000, $2500, and sometimes $5000 when we are speaking about homes valued under $1 million in reconstruction value. Every deductible offers a percentage discount off the base premium of your insurance policy. These percentages are filed with the New York State Department of Financial Services and are approved when insurance companies file their rates with the state. This is important because deductible options between different carriers can range significantly.

Get 10 Free quotes Home Insurance

Let’s look at the difference in premium and risk between a $500 deductible and a $2500 deductible. The increase in risk to you is $2000 ($2500-$500=$2000). If we were to increase our policy deductible from $500 to $2500 the premium savings would approach 30%. If your policy was $2500/yr you could be looking at a savings of as much as $750/yr. That would mean that after just 2.7 years you would be ahead of the game in premium savings! ($750 x 2.7=$2025) You still need peace of mind when purchasing insurance, so if your risk appetite or current financial position will not allow for a $2500 hit then maybe it’s not the best option for you.

What is a good deductible for home insurance?

How likely are you to put a claim in for $600? Clients call me all the time wanting to file a claim for small amounts. “My screen door blew off” or “Johnny dropped his toy truck on the ceramic tile”. I highly advise against this, especially if it’s close to your deductible because if you have a few small claims you’re very likely to be dropped by the insurance company. Finding new insurance after a few small claims can be a nightmare and cost thousands of extra dollars. The insurance company’s motto is “Frequency leads to Severity” and they like to stick to that philosophy.

So we now know that many factors go into choosing the best deductible for your situation including; risk appetite, financial position, and premium. My personal opinion is to pay the insurance company the least amount of money, fix the screen door when damaged, and save the insurance for catastrophic events like fire, hurricanes, and pipe bursts.

Shop for competitive rates on any type of insurance!


View the Coastal Insurance Video Library  to find helpful video’s explaining everything from, how to save money on Homeowners Insurance to an easy explanation of Flood Insurance. Call today (631-782-3175) to speak with one of our underwriting experts.  Fast Quotes, A.M. Best Rates & Free Advice.


www.GIFCreator.me om7inW 1

Home Insurance Articles

Need assistance now?

Give us a call:
(631) 782-3175

Homeowners Insurance Articles

Helpful Home Insurance Articles

Insurance Market Tightens Amid Higher Claims and Regulation

Insurance Market Tightens Amid Higher Claims and Regulation

Florida and California steal the headlines with seasonal hurricane and wildfire losses, but across the nation, insurers are tightening underwriting standards. In some cases, insurers are pulling out of certain zip codes or states altogether. It seems counterintuitive...

How Does Inflation Impact My Homeowners Insurance?

How Does Inflation Impact My Homeowners Insurance?

The recent spike in inflation affects nearly every aspect of life, including insurance costs. But inflation can also affect how well your home is protected against common losses, such as fires, burst pipes, and other risks covered by a standard home insurance policy....